Skip to content

Shopify POS vs Square in 2026: Which Costs Less for In-Person Sales

Plans, card rates, hardware and two worked months compared, plus the sales mix where Shopify's lower fee per sale and online rate win.

8 min read

Square is cheaper than Shopify POS for most in-person sellers in 2026. Square's Free plan costs $0 a month with tapped cards at 2.6% + 15¢, while Shopify POS needs a Shopify plan from $39 a month (Basic, monthly billing) with tapped cards at 2.6% + 10¢, as of October 28, 2026. In our worked month, Square wins at both a $15 and a $60 ticket ($285.00 against $315.67 at the larger one), while Shopify wins for shops with a busy online store.

FinanceRadar data: the cost example on our POS system rankings, checked October 28, 2026, puts Square's Free plan at $320 a month in card fees on $10,000 of in-person sales at a $25 ticket, with rates read on Square's page on October 27, 2026. Shopify has to beat that figure with a subscription on top, which is the whole contest in one number.

SquareShopify POS
Entry planFree, $0 a month per locationBasic, $39 a month (monthly billing)
Next plansPlus $49, Premium $149 per locationGrow $105, Advanced $399; POS Pro $89 per location
Tapped card, entry plan2.6% + 15¢2.6% + 10¢
Tapped card, top self-serve plan2.4% + 15¢ (Premium)2.4% + 10¢ (Advanced)
Online card, entry plan3.3% + 30¢2.9% + 30¢
Inventory toolsItem library with inventory tracking on FreeInventory management in POS Pro
Countertop hardwareReader $59, Terminal $299POS Terminal $349, with your own phone or tablet

Prices and rates read on Square's and Shopify's own pricing and hardware pages on October 28, 2026.

What a month of in-person sales costs

We priced $10,000 a month in tapped card sales at two ticket sizes: $15, roughly 667 sales, like a coffee bar, and $60, roughly 167 sales, like a boutique. Each figure is our arithmetic: the percentage times monthly sales, plus the fixed cents times the number of sales, plus the plan's monthly fee.

PlanMonthly fee$15 ticket month$60 ticket month
Square Free$0$360.00$285.00
Shopify Basic$39$365.67$315.67
Square Plus$49$399.00$324.00
Shopify Grow$105$421.67$371.67
Shopify Basic with POS Pro$128$454.67$404.67

Square Free wins both scenarios. At a $15 ticket, Shopify's 5¢ lower fee per sale saves about $33.33 a month, which almost covers the Basic subscription but not quite. By our arithmetic, Shopify Basic overtakes Square Free once a shop makes about 780 in-person card sales a month at the same volume. At a $60 ticket, the saving shrinks to about $8.33, and Square stays $30.67 ahead.

A store that needs Shopify's inventory tools pays for POS Pro on top, $89 a month per location, billed yearly. That pushes Shopify's in-person cost to about 2,560 sales a month before it matches Square Free, by our arithmetic, so the subscription has to earn its keep through features rather than rates.

Where Shopify wins: selling online too

Shopify's case is the online store. Its Basic plan charges 2.9% + 30¢ on online cards against 3.3% + 30¢ on Square Free, a 0.4-point gap. With the boutique month above, Shopify Basic catches up with Square Free once online card sales pass about $7,667 a month, by our arithmetic. Above that, every extra online dollar widens Shopify's lead.

Square Plus closes most of that gap, because its online rate falls to 2.9% + 30¢ as well, for $49 a month. A shop comparing the two paid tiers is really choosing between Square's 15¢ and Shopify's 10¢ per in-person sale, and between their software.

Dimension by dimension

Monthly cost: Square wins. Square has a real $0 plan for in-person selling, while the cheapest plan on Shopify's POS pricing page is Basic at $39 a month. A limited-time Shopify offer of $1 a month for the first 3 months softens the start, but the list price applies after that.

In-person card rate: Shopify wins on the fixed fee. Both charge 2.6% on the entry plan, and Shopify's fixed fee is 5¢ lower. Each step up lowers Shopify's percentage too, to 2.5% + 10¢ on Grow and 2.4% + 10¢ on Advanced.

Online selling: Shopify wins. Its entry online rate is 0.4 points lower, and its plans are built around an online store first. Square Free includes an online store too, at the higher rate.

Inventory and staff: Square wins at the low end. Square's Free plan keeps an item library with inventory tracking. Shopify Basic gives limited staff access to the POS and returns only at the original location; unlimited staff logins come with Grow, and inventory management, staff roles and returns at any location come with POS Pro.

Hardware: Square wins on the entry price. Square's contactless and chip reader costs $59 and its Terminal with a receipt printer $299, with financing on the Terminal. Shopify's POS Terminal costs $349 and works with a phone or tablet you supply.

Third-party processing: Shopify's catch. Shopify lets you use a third-party payment provider, but charges 2% per sale on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced for it. On $10,000 a month, that is $200 on Basic before your processor's own fees.

Fees beyond the card rate

Square's headline rates hide a few extras worth checking. Keyed-in or card-on-file payments cost 3.5% + 15¢ on every Square plan, and loading a gift card costs 2.5% on Free and Plus but nothing on Premium. Self-serve kiosks and kitchen screens are add-ons: Square Kiosk costs $99 a month per device and requires Plus or Premium, and the KDS app costs $30 a month per device on Plus.

Shopify's extras sit in its plan structure rather than in per-sale fees. POS Pro is charged per location, so a second store doubles it, and the third-party processing fee applies to every sale you route elsewhere. Count these before comparing the two headline rates, because an add-on can outweigh a 5¢ difference per sale.

Who should pick which

Square fits a counter, cart, salon or market stall that sells mostly in person and wants no subscription. It also fits a new business testing demand, since the Free plan costs nothing in a slow month. Its weak spot is the 15¢ fixed fee on small tickets and the 3.3% + 30¢ online rate on Free. See Square POS and Square Payments.

Shopify POS fits a brand whose online store already runs on Shopify and that wants one catalog and one customer list for the web and the counter. Its weak spot is cost at the counter: a subscription before any sale, and $89 more per location for real retail tools. Shopify is not in our catalog; see Shopify's POS pricing.

For a wider field, our ranking of the best POS systems for retail stores prices eight options over a first year, and the best POS systems for salons covers booking-led businesses. If you are new to the category, see what a POS system is and what a POS system costs. Processor-only options are in credit card processing with no monthly fee, our credit card processing rankings and the payment processing fee statistics.

How we compared

We read Square's POS software pricing page, Square's hardware page, Shopify's POS pricing page and Shopify's hardware store on October 28, 2026. Shopify's plan prices are on monthly billing, and POS Pro is billed yearly; Shopify also sells yearly plans. Scenario totals are our arithmetic on printed rates for tapped cards only, and they leave out hardware, tax, refunds, chargebacks and promotions. Fractional sales counts are kept unrounded in the sums.

Sources: Square POS software pricing, Square hardware, Shopify POS pricing and Shopify hardware store.

Financeradar may earn a commission from some links; it never affects rankings (how we make money).

This page is general information, not personalized financial advice. Confirm current plan prices and card rates with Square and Shopify before you switch, because both change plans and promotions.

Cite this: FinanceRadar, "Shopify POS vs Square in 2026: Which Costs Less for In-Person Sales," November 2026.

FAQ

Is Shopify POS or Square cheaper in 2026?

Square is cheaper for in-person selling. Its Free plan costs $0 a month at 2.6% + 15¢ per tapped card, while Shopify Basic costs $39 a month at 2.6% + 10¢, as of October 28, 2026. On $10,000 a month at a $60 ticket, that is $285.00 at Square and $315.67 at Shopify, by our arithmetic.

When does Shopify POS cost less than Square?

At the same in-person volume, Shopify Basic overtakes Square Free at about 780 card sales a month, thanks to its lower fixed fee. With a busy online store it wins sooner: with the boutique-style month above, Shopify catches up once online card sales pass about $7,667 a month.

Does Shopify POS have a free plan?

Shopify's POS pricing page starts at the Basic plan, $39 a month on monthly billing, after a free trial, and inventory management sits in the POS Pro add-on at $89 a month per location, billed yearly. Square's Free plan has no monthly fee.

Can I use Square payments with Shopify?

Shopify allows third-party payment providers but adds its own fee per sale: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced. On the scenario's monthly sales that is $200 on Basic before the other processor's charges, which usually makes Shopify Payments the cheaper route on Shopify.

What hardware do Square and Shopify sell?

Square sells a contactless and chip reader for $59 and an all-in-one Terminal with a receipt printer for $299. Shopify's POS Terminal costs $349 and pairs with your own phone or tablet, with stands, printers and scanners sold separately.

From the team behind Financeradar

Reach finance and tech readers in their inbox

Financeradar is built by Dupple, publisher of Finpresso (34K finance readers) and Techpresso (810K+ tech professionals). Sponsor an issue and get a report with the domains that clicked.

Work with us
small-businesspaymentspos
Share this article

Written by

FinanceRadar

This article was drafted with AI assistance. See our editorial policy and methodology.